Locatedness and the objectivity of interpretation in practice-based research
University of Hertfordshire
MetadataShow full item record
This paper addresses the question of interpretation in practice-based research by arguing that all practice is 'located', where this 'location' ensures the objectivity of interpretation. Another way of making the point is to claim that all art practice is made and perceived under interpretation. There is never a moment of 'pure' or 'innocent' looking at a work. Even an emotional response is located within the mode of interpretation that has human beings encounter the world through emotional states. Even perceiving a work as a work of art is an interpretation, resulting from us looking at certain objects through the concept 'art'. In this paper, I defend the position that interpretation runs all the way down, so to speak, in the making and viewing of works of art. More specifically, I argue that it is interpretation's fundamental, 'all the way down' status which provides the condition for the objectivity of interpretation. To say that an artwork always occurs under interpretation means that it always occurs in relation to certain concepts and themes in the history and theory of art and aesthetics. The objectivity of the interpretation stems from working out and reflecting upon how the artwork is located, how the interpretation occurs in relation to these concepts and themes. It is never a case of concepts and themes simply being referred to. Neither is it a matter of merely imposing theory onto the artwork. Rather, the act of having to locate the work through interpretation will mean, for example, that some concepts are thrown together for the first time, as in the case of metaphor, or that an observation is made which challenges current understanding within a territory. These interventions need working out: they need to be described, evaluated, and applied, where these processes are not purely written but interactions between writing and practice. I set out this position in detail, and show how it is supported by Kantian aesthetics and recent Deleuzian scholarship. I also provide an example of recent practice-based doctoral study at Cardiff School of Art and Design which (a) demonstrates how this approach leads to the generation of 'located' objective research outcomes, and (b) demonstrates the kind of language in which such outcomes are described.
Working Papers in Art and Design, Volume 5
Full text available from http://sitem.herts.ac.uk/artdes_research/papers/wpades/vol5/ccabs.html
Available online: http://sitem.herts.ac.uk/artdes_research/papers/wpades/vol5/ccfull.html Full journal available from: http://sitem.herts.ac.uk/artdes_research/papers/wpades/vol5/index.html
Showing items related by title, author, subject and abstract.
(Cambridge University Press, 2008-10-17)This collection of essays deals with the issues that animated Conceptual art in the Anglophone world. It offers readers a wealth of new research on the earliest international exhibitions of Conceptual art, new interpretation ...
Counsell, John (IEEE Conference Publications, 2003-07-16)Experience gained in associating interpretative VRML modelling with real-time video has demonstrated that it is an effective technique for explaining the content of the video image. However searching the VRML model requires ...
Unknown author (Rodopi, 2008-10-17)Originally presented to an international conference on Avant-Garde Cinema at Edinburgh University in 2004, this text investigates montage films of the 1920s in the context of avant-garde theory. The observation that new ...