Ontological developments in contemporary art and their implications for value systems in art education
Cardiff Metropolitan University
MetadataShow full item record
The subject of this study, which engages philosophy, art and the teaching of art, asks how art can be taught if it can be any thing. I characterise this status as 'open', meaning that it is epistemologically and ontologically unstable in ways which challenge our understanding of what an 'artwork' might constitute. The research looks to debates in the philosophy of art, for example, the definitional challenge of art, but especially to attempts to identify where the ontological distinctiveness of art lies if physicality fails to explain such distinctiveness. I argue that, although such debates have a relevance for the teaching of art at undergraduate level, this relevance is not widely acknowledged in the literature of art teaching. I first examine how openness is recognized and dealt with in art schools through the Benchmark Statement for art and design. I use a case study to explore the implications of open art with educational practitioners. I then ask whether art has always been problematical to teach and whether it is any more so in the context of contemporary art practices. Two accounts of value in art teaching (Ginsborg and de Duve) are examined in order to show how differently the practices which reflect that value can be interpreted and how the value is shifting as particular theories manifest themselves in art schools. I explore the relationship between theory and practice in the art school context, identifying six ways in which the term theory can be interpreted. Each way has implications for how art teaching is understood although I give special attention to an aspect of philosophical theory – the ontological structure of artworks – to argue that the teaching of art would meet the challenge of open art more readily by acknowledging, more overtly than is currently evident, the ontology of artworks.
A REFERENCE copy of this thesis is held in the Special Collections Room L2.04 in Llandaff Library. For access please email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Showing items related by title, author, subject and abstract.
THE FACTORS THAT INFLUENCE ONTOLOGICAL SECURITY, LINKED SPECIFICALLY TO THE COACH-ATHLETE RELATIONSHIP: AN AUTO-ETHNOGRAPHIC STUDY OF CRICKET COACHING Eccleshare, James (University of Wales Institute Cardiff, 2011-03-15)The primary purpose of this study is to examine the notion of ontological security within the coach athlete relationship. Previous research has highlighted the necessity to develop a trusting and secure environment for ...
The factors that influence ontological security, linked specifically to the coach-athlete relationship: an auto-ethnographic study of cricket coaching Eccleshare, James (University of Wales, 2011)The primary purpose of this study is to examine the notion of ontological security within the coach athlete relationship. Previous research has highlighted the necessity to develop a trusting and secure environment for ...
Biggs, Michael (University of Wales Institute Cardiff, 2011)The main purpose of the study was to investigate the factors that influence secondary school Physical Education (PE) teachers’ selection of teaching styles during key stage three (KS3) lessons. Two experienced teachers ...