Do artists use linear perspective to depict visual space?
MetadataShow full item record
The question of how to accurately depict visual space has fascinated artists, architects, scientists and philosophers for hundreds of years. Many have argued that linear perspective, which is based on well-understood laws of optics and geometry, is the natural way to record visual space. Others have argued that linear perspective projections fail to account for important features of visual experience, and have proposed various curvilinear, subjective, and hyperbolic forms of perspective instead. In this study we compare three sets of artistic depictions of real-world scenes to linear perspective versions (photographs) of the same scenes. They include a series of paintings made by one of the authors, a selection of landscape paintings by Paul Cézanne, and a set of drawings made as part of a controlled experiment by people with art training. When comparing the artworks to the photographs depicting the same visual space we found consistent differences. In the artworks the part of the scene corresponding to the central visual field was enlarged compared to the photograph and the part corresponding to the peripheral field was compressed. We consider a number of factors that could explain these results.
Pepperell, R and Haertel, M. (2014) 'Do artists use linear perspective to depict visual space?', Perception, 43(5), pp. 395-416
This article was published in Perception on 1 January 2014 (online), available at https://doi.org/10.1068/p7692
Showing items related by title, author, subject and abstract.
Can artistic methods be used to improve the perception of depth in pictures?: an investigation into two methods Baldwin, Joseph (Cardiff Metropolitan University, 2015)This PhD research investigates two artistic imaging methods based on modeling human visual experience, Vision-Space and Fovography, in order to ascertain whether they are better able to represent pictorial depth than ...
Baldwin, Joseph; Burleigh, Alistair; Pepperell, Robert (Sage, 2014)Which is the most accurate way to depict space in our visual eld? Linear perspective, a form of geometrical perspective, has traditionally been regarded as the correct method of depicting visual space. But artists have ...
Koenderink, Jan; van Doorn, Andrea; Pinna, Baingio; Pepperell, Robert (2015)Are pictorial renderings that deviate from linear perspective necessarily ‘wrong’? Are those in per- fect linear perspective necessarily ‘right’? Are wrong depictions in some sense ‘impossible’? Linear perspective is the ...