Post-Categorical Auditory Distraction in Serial Short-Term Memory: Insights from Increased Task-Load and Task-Type
Marsh, John E
American Psychological Association
MetadataShow full item record
Task-irrelevant speech impairs short-term serial recall appreciably. On the interference-by-process account, the processing of physical (i.e., pre-categorical) changes in speech yields order cues that conflict with the serial-ordering process deployed to perform the serial recall task. In this view, the post-categorical properties (e.g., phonology, meaning) of speech play no role. The present study reassessed the implications of recent demonstrations of auditory post-categorical distraction in serial recall that have been taken as support for an alternative, attentional-diversion, account of the irrelevant speech effect. Focusing on the disruptive effect of emotionally valent compared to neutral words on serial recall, we show that the distracter-valence effect is eliminated under conditions—high task-encoding load—thought to shield against attentional diversion whereas the general effect of speech (neutral words compared to quiet) remains unaffected (Experiment 1). Furthermore, the distracter-valence effect generalizes to a task that does not require the processing of serial order—the missing-item task—while the effect of speech per se is attenuated in this task (Experiment 2). We conclude that post-categorical auditory distraction phenomena in serial short-term memory are incidental: they are observable in such a setting but, unlike the acoustically driven irrelevant speech effect, are not integral to it. As such, the findings support a duplex-mechanism account over a unitary view of auditory distraction.
Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition;
Marsh, J.E., Yang, J, Qualter, P, Cassandra, R, Perham, N, Vachon, F and Hughes, R.W. (2017) 'Post-categorical auditory distraction in serial short-term memory: Insights from increased task load and task type', Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/xlm0000492
This article published in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition on 01 February 2018 available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/xlm0000492
- Import 
Showing items related by title, author, subject and abstract.
Russell, Liberty Valentine (Cardiff Metropolitan University, 2017-06-01)Research surrounding auditory distraction has led to reports of a new effect; the effect a deviant word has in an otherwise repeated sequence (Escera, Alho, Winkler & Naatanen, 1998). Past studies have looked into this ...
Perham, Nick; Banbury, S.P.; Jones, D.M. (Taylor and Francis, 2007-05-01)Most research on auditory distraction on task performance focuses on those features of the sound that determine a drop in efficiency, with scant regard for examining the processing properties inherent in the focal task. ...
Marsh, John E.; Perham, Nick; Sörqvist, P.; Jones, Dylan M. (Springer US, 2014-11)Three experiments investigated memory for semantic information with the goal of determining boundary conditions for the manifestation of semantic auditory distraction. Irrelevant speech disrupted the free recall of semantic ...