Humpty Dumpty’s guide to tax law: Rules, principles and certainty in Taxation
MetadataShow full item record
Tax systems are, most commonly, rules-based. This gives the impression of techno-rationality in the interpretation of the numbers from which tax bills are derived. In fact, uncertainty and complexity in tax rules are seen as promoting tax avoidance behaviour, as avoiders exploit this complexity. Some authors have advocated that this can be combated by replacing rules-based tax legislation with principles-based legislation, giving tax authorities and the courts the power to interpret legislation purposively. This paper demonstrates by reference to a number of UK tax cases that rules-based legislation already embodies the hidden operation of state power as judges have considerable discretion in the interpretation of rules. The paper goes on to argue that principles-based legislation would further empower the state vis-à-vis the citizen. While this might be intuitively appealing to the vast majority of taxpayers not engaged in tax avoidance, it brings with it the hidden danger of a fundamental alteration of the balance of power between the state and all citizens, and should therefore be treated with caution.
Critical Perspectives on Accounting
James, M. (2010) 'Humpty Dumpty's guide to tax law: Rules, principles and certainty in taxation', Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 21(7), pp.573-583.
This article was published in Critical Perspectives on Accounting on 27 May 2010 (online), available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cpa.2010.03.007
Showing items related by title, author, subject and abstract.
Kaehne, A.; Taylor, Helen (Sage Journals, 2015-08-06)Conducting a public consultation is a popular way to draw on wider expertise in framing legislation in the UK. In Wales, low scrutinising capacity of a relatively small legislative chamber and limited civil service resources ...
Vaughan-Atkins, Grant (Cardiff Metropolitan University, 2013)Disability Legislation has had a big impact on the sports facilities with more facilities becoming accessible to those with disabilities but there are still barriers that exist within facilities especially those within ...
Howells, Gareth (University of Wales, 2011-10-25)Health and safety has become a major issue in the workplace since the introduction of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974. The HSWA 1974 then established the health and safety commission who are responsible for the ...